Park Ranger Arrests Woman For Attempting To Record Her Own Traffic Stop

celia_sullivan.jpg

Celia Sullivan, a 50-year-old mother of two from Utah, enjoys hiking through the Capitol Reef National Park to take photos.

But it ended up getting her arrested on federal charges on the Fourth of July.

All because she tried to record the park ranger who had pulled her over.

Sullivan was charged with “disobeying a lawful order” and “resisting arrest” after she was pulled over by Park Ranger Steven Powers for allegedly failing to “maintain level of traffic.”

Sullivan said Powers, pictured below, was tailgating her for several miles as she was trying to relocate the spot where she had left her tripod earlier that day.

park_ranger_steven_powers.jpg

Sullivan described her experience detail in a Facebook note within 48 hours after her experience. She is a longtime Photography is Not a Crime reader. She goes by Pixie in the comments section.

I’ve cut and pasted that note on a PDF to allow everybody to read it (in case her Facebook page is not public).

The PDF note is very lengthy, but I recommend reading it to get the full grasp of her story.

Essentially, she was pulled over for driving too slow. The ranger then ordered her out of the car because he suspected of being under the influence.

And when she didn’t get out of her car fast enough, informing the ranger that she wanted to grab her phone to record the encounter, she was dragged out of the car and handcuffed.

I told PRSP (Park Ranger Steven Powers) that I was going to record him and said just a minute, let me grab my phone. PRSP decided that he didn’t have to be patient with me (like a good cop would), which is when he opened the door to my vehicle without my permission. I remember telling him just a second, I’m grabbing the documents and I grabbed my wallet too. I WAS NOT SCARED AT ALL. I was irritated but had no problem getting out of the vehicle but I was going to protect myself just in case. I had nothing to fear if he was good cop, and the video WOULD protect me if he was a bad cop.

And I remember telling him the video was for MY PROTECTION. I didn’t know what kind of person PRSP was, and he had a taser AND a gun.

I was all alone. Don’t forget that.

PRSP didn’t like the fact I was getting ready to record things because he grabbed my left wrist in an attempt to get me to drop the phone. I then said I can get out the car by myself, and turned and placed my feet on the ground and stood. This is where I complied with BOTH of his direct orders: I was out of the car, and I had my papers with me.

But he didn’t give me a chance to do anything else since he still had a hold of my wrist. With one motion, he twisted my left arm around to my back, and then at the same time saying you are under arrest for disobeying a direct order. I sank to my knees, dropped my papers phone and wallet and said over and over again you’ve got to be kidding, you’ve got to be kidding, are you kidding me.

She remained in handcuffs for 90 minutes before she was finally released.

Here's the link to the PDF that contains her entire story.

Comments

With no witnesses and no recording its her word against his, guess who wins.

I was told there was audio, I have to get it from the US Attorney's office and so far they haven't returned my call.

Isn't it interesting that Park Rangers don't have video cameras in their vehicles?

The Wayne County Sheriff vehicle was equipped with audio & video. Unfortunately, it wasn't on while they were on scene.

When I asked the deputy sheriff why he showed up, he told me he was "bored". :)

What a horrible situation to go through.

Time to get some legal counsel.

It will be a long and infuriating process but you deserve Justice. I hope you pursue it to the end.

There would have been a third reliable witness, Celia's video record.

The cop has admited that he prevented her from filming right.
In UK law the definition of a person includes; a company and even a camera.

The cop used force to intimidate the third witness, so his standing as a witness is diminished significantly.

She should print a couple copies of her story and take them to court with her. It is a very well written account of what happened, and I doubt the park ranger will be nearly as articulate in court. If she has a judge with any sense of justice/common sense, the case should be decided in her favor (I really hope this is the case).

Good luck to you Pixie, please keep us updated, hire a good attorney, and file charges of your own.

Thank you Rance. Without video I thought it was important to get every detail on paper as soon as possible.

IF there is ever a "next time" screw the phone, the laptop is coming out, so the LEO can see themselves on screen while they're being a jerk~!

Pixie, I think you should re-write your story to include just the facts of what happened, "I said" then "He said". Just the what, when and where of the story. Don't omit anything, and don't try to guess the officers intention or what he was thinking. It's fine to vent online if it helps you work through your anger, but it probably will not help with a complaint against this officer. A judge would never let you submit something you wrote about the incident anyway. It is not evidence.

I didn't say she should submit it... Just use it to refresh her memory about the events while she's in court. Court can be very nerve racking for some people, and after it is all over with, hindsight kicks in with 'Dammit, why didn't I think of that in court'.

Don't forget, the story I wrote started as a verbal recording I made immediately after being released from the handcuffs, I started it in front of the rangers on scene once they gave me my phone back.

When I got to my camp spot I typed it all out. All I did after that was correct some grammar and stuff.

And my brain was bathed in epinephrine, which has been proven to improve memory. That is how you can remember your 10th birthday party when you got the puppy, but have no idea what you were doing last Tuesday at 3 pm :)

The court would only be interested in your feelings if they were submitted as 'Contemporaneous notes'. And as such, the court would have to pay them high regard, they are a sort of sub-witness to the scene.
But then I am versed in UK law not US.

"The court would only be interested in your feelings if they were submitted as 'Contemporaneous notes'. And as such, the court would have to pay them high regard, they are a sort of sub-witness to the scene.
But then I am versed in UK law not US"

Then you have no idea what you are talking about. You might as well be quoting the laws of Thailand for all it matters to a traffic stop in Utah.

Well said sir. I stand corrected. Thank you for informing me that the rights of a citizen in the USA are inferior to those in the UK and Thailand : I had always been under the assumption it was the opposite.

Actually, my point was that you have no idea what you are talking about when it comes to US laws.

That point still stands.

I wrote the notes for my reference, because Park Ranger Steven Powers circumvented my recording of events. It has been proven with tests that the longer you go without recording your memories the more they fade. I wanted to guarantee that I had all the circumstances documented while the memories were strong.

It sounds like you have great leeway for notes in the UK.

Sorry, typical Utah. Lived there for two decades.

I had a young cop try that tailgate with the brites on me, hehehe. It was a 25MPH zone and I made a right-angle left-turn. And I mean "right-angle"! It was in my Vette which corners like it's on rails. It was hilarious. I maintained the full 25MPH and was half a block away before he hit his lights. It seems he skidded past the street when I turned and he had to back up to make the turn. LOL. I stopped, parked and waited for him. He gave me a DUI "Look at this pen tip" test but there was nothing he could get me for and let me go. Me thinks the driver's seat of his squad vehicle has a stain on it.

She needs a copy of the dash cam asap before it is erased. Nothing better than showing a cop to be a fool with his own tools.

They told me "no dash cam" in Park Ranger vehicles. I guess the gov is too poor to equip their LEO's with proper equipment. :/

Which is why I think Park Ranger Steven Powers felt he could go over the line--- Can you imagine the picture? 5'11" Park Ranger with a badge, gun and taser handcuffing a 5' grandma?

I tend to get followed alot by cops in Utah.

(Utahn myself, been living her for almost 20 years now) and every time I get followed by one I usually pull into a 7-11 or Maverick.

Honestly its grating knowing that they are following you so they can pull you over if you mess up by 1 inch.

A 7 page pdf about a traffic stop. Wow.

So basically she refused to get out of the car when directed to by an officer on a legal traffic stop?

When you are stopped and the officer tells you to exit the car, you don't get to tell him to wait while you get your camera or anything else. Who knows what you are digging around in the car for? That is why she was arrested, not because she was going to try to be Scoop McGee the Crime Reporter.

Really Johnny? Can you possibly be serious?

You may or may not know this since you claim to be a cop, but a lot of people do not know your rules. Not everyone has been pulled over in past or had interactions with a cop. People may not know that you would expect them to move a split second after being to get out of the car.

Many law abiding people who have never been in a situation like that may not know how to act and may reasonably think it is okay to get their papers and their phone when exiting their car.

I certainly hope all cops do not have a short fuse like this cop and you. Is there a law that says that all lawful orders must be complied with immediately? There has to be some common sense involved in a traffic stop from both sides.

Forcing someone to comply in an instant seems like more of a power play than anything else. Imagine if everyone in this world acted/reacted like this cop when they did their job. What a fucked up world that would be.

Jim

You said it Scott, "common sense...from both sides". Pixie used none at all! In fact, it sounds like she went out of her way to do just the opposite.

Johnny, it would have been a 1 page PDF about a "traffic stop" but turned into a longer PDF about an illegal arrest!

I did get out of the car, within 30 seconds of him asking me to. I complied with his direct order(s) IN THE ORDER THEY WERE GIVEN TO ME. How was I supposed to know which order was "MORE IMPORTANT"? My crystal ball was in the back, with the hatchet and numerous other "weapons" that most of us call camping gear :)

I was prepared to prove I was not under the influence but was never given the opportunity. He was a jerk and arrested me to prove he could.

Is it so hard for you to admit that there are jerks with badges? Do you think a badge automatically makes someone less of an asshole?

If you read my store at all you'd realize that the PHONE was in my lap (I use it as an IPOD and was listening to music with my headphones when I was pulled over-) SOOOOOO, NO DIGGING IN MY CAR ETC ETC ETC. I was holding the blackberry and pushing buttons (attempting to starting the video program) when he got irritated with me.

and who is scoop mcgee? are you saying I went out LOOKING for trouble? Seriously Johnny, you have issues. I have the name of a good therapist, do you want it?

Pixie

Pixie, not such a good idea to drive while wearing headphones. It is illegal in many states, as well (not Utah, however).

It may be hard for some individuals to understand the remoteness of this place. The entire COUNTY has only 2,000 residents! There are no radio stations anywhere near Capitol Reef National Park. If you don't bring your own music you have none!

Your letter says you were angry and argumentative even before the recording issue, even before he walked up to your car. Yelling out your window as he is walking up to your car, not really a good way to kick things off.

It took you 30 seconds to get out of the car after he asked you to and that was with him opening your car door and grabbing you. I can get my blackberry and my ipod into record mode in about 7 seconds. If a police officer tells you to get out of the car you are required to get out. Police can order occupants out of a car, you may not like it but they can do so. Next time listen and you won't have any problems.

" I started thinking he’s just
waiting for me to get out of the park so he can ram me and cause me to lose control, and then he has me.
Now I COULDN’T pull over! I started to panic, and I reached up and moved my rear view mirror so I
could see clearly ahead and started crying. I was going to have to make a run for it as soon as the speed
limit changed at the border

Wow, sounds like you were in fear for your life at that point but you were still concerned about the speed limit. At that point I would think you would be happy to get pulled over so you can tell the police about the maniac following you. A speeding ticket is a small price to pay when you are being following by somebody you think might be trying to kill you.

You claim his he was right on your bumper and the lights were blinding you. Seems if he was that close the lights would be hitting the back of your jeep and not bothering you. How high is this truck he was driving?

"I’ve been an avid reader of CopBlock, Carlos Miller and other websites"

If I were you I wouldn't practice the opinions expressed on this website in your real life situations.

Never talk to the police.

NEVER heed advice given by fake cops over the interwebs.

-->"I’ve been an avid reader of CopBlock, Carlos Miller and other websites"

"If I were you I wouldn't practice the opinions expressed on this website in your real life situations."

Okay. But what if they're right...and you're wrong?

Park Ranger Steven Powers had no right to even get angry with me, I was telling him how his actions terrified me and that I knew they were illegal. Did you read the part where i mentioned he was following me with his BRIGHT LIGHTS ON? And you say I have no right to be angry?

Would YOU have been angry?

I have a great quote from someone named LawDog: "It was hammered into me at the Academy that a Peace Officer could not be insulted or offended. You could arrest someone for flipping off a non-LEO in public, and you could arrest someone for cussing a non-LEO in public, but you could not arrest that person for flipping or cussing you (as a Peace Officer)."

And then, your final insult to me is that I'm foolish to be informed.

Seriously bad style, lawman. BAD STYLE.

"Okay. But what if they're right...and you're wrong?"

You should verify if they are right and not take whatever they say as gospel.

"Park Ranger Steven Powers had no right to even get angry with me, I was telling him how his actions terrified me and that I knew they were illegal. Did you read the part where i mentioned he was following me with his BRIGHT LIGHTS ON? And you say I have no right to be angry?"

You were angry with him, calling him names, but yet he is supposed to treat you the same as the person he stops who isn't yelling at him and calling him names? If you want to get angry over alleged bright lights than address it with him like an adult.

"I have a great quote from someone named LawDog: "It was hammered into me at the Academy that a Peace Officer could not be insulted or offended. You could arrest someone for flipping off a non-LEO in public, and you could arrest someone for cussing a non-LEO in public, but you could not arrest that person for flipping or cussing you (as a Peace Officer)."

I don't know what academy he went to but if he's arresting people for flipping the bird than he needs to be retrained.

"And then, your final insult to me is that I'm foolish to be informed"

No, your foolish because your not informed

@ lawman:

I never said I was yelling at him. Those were YOUR words.

I said I told him (in similar sentiments) that he was a piss poor park ranger. I've met a few so I should know. He was NOT a nice guy. If his friends say different I'll listen. But then they'll have to listen to my story too~

Stop backing up the jerks. Be a good guy! I know you can do it lawman.

"I never said I was yelling at him. Those were YOUR words"

From your novel "I rolled my window down and then placed my hands on the steering wheel (I know proper police
procedure) and he shined a light at my car door. I yelled out that I was a 50 yr old grandma and that he had
nothing to fear"

Your words, not mine

@ pixie

"Johnny, it would have been a 1 page PDF about a "traffic stop" but turned into a longer PDF about an illegal arrest!"

Nothing illegal about it other than your refusal to get out of the car when directed to.

"Is it so hard for you to admit that there are jerks with badges? Do you think a badge automatically makes someone less of an asshole?"

I would ask you the same thing about people with cameras. Once again I seem to get the vibe off you and others here that if you are recording, you get special privileges.

"If you read my store at all you'd realize that the PHONE was in my lap (I use it as an IPOD and was listening to music with my headphones when I was pulled over-) SOOOOOO, NO DIGGING IN MY CAR ETC ETC ETC. "

Then it shouldn't have taken you that long to get out of your car.

"are you saying I went out LOOKING for trouble? "

Not at first but you certainly wanted to cause trouble once you were pulled over. By your own admission you insulted the guy, was argumentative, and emotional. Sorry you don't handle stress very well but getting that worked up on a traffic stop and trying to take it out on the officer is not a good idea. I would bet that you were also deliberately being slow to get out of the car to screw with the officer. I've had upset people on traffic stops do that as a passive aggressive way of trying to gain control of the situation.

If you had just stayed calm and done what the officer required, you would have been on your way in a couple of minutes.

Johnny Troll says:
"Once again I (gollum, gollum) seem to get the vibe off you and others here (gollum) that if you are recording, you get special (gollum, gollum, gollum) privileges."

We do. And we get a gold star for every cop thug bagged on tape.

You would know this if you ever ventured forth from the blackness of mommy's basement.

@ JohnnyLaw,

You probably don't understand what epinephrine is, or what it does to emotions, but it's the thing that makes you run when you're scared. You've been scared before, haven't you?

so, when you say things like "If you had just stayed calm and done what the officer required, you would have been on your way in a couple of minutes." I know you're right, and I even said so to him after the cuffs were on (not an apology, but trying to tell him what a mistake he made over a simple traffic stop).

But see, it wasn't my actions that created the problem, it was Park Ranger Steven Powers' actions that started it. I was only reacting to his actions! I went from flight to fight in less than 10 seconds. But he was the pursuer, he initiated the contact and handled it badly. HE was the cause of the epinephrine rush.

But *I* should have been the patient one. (yea, I would think that is how another LEO would think: no bad cops, only bad citizens...)

And I've never stepped away from an injustice because of fear. You know how little dogs go right up to the big dogs and start barking? Well, try being a female in RURAL UTAH and poor and short to boot, and you might understand what I go through every single day: the looks, the discrimination, the men that think I'm weak.

I don't have physical stature, but you can't take this brain away from me. :)

one more thing...

-->"Johnny, it would have been a 1 page PDF about a "traffic stop" but turned into a longer PDF about an illegal arrest!"

"Nothing illegal about it other than your refusal to get out of the car when directed to."

I GOT OUT OF THE CAR ON MY OWN VOLITION AND DID NOT RESIST ONE SINGLE SECOND ONCE OUT OF THE CAR.

How is that refusing? How is that resisting?

Johnny is the website's official troll. He's not actually a cop. Don't let him rile you up.

"I would ask you the same thing about people with cameras. Once again I seem to get the vibe off you and others here that if you are recording, you get special privileges."

Those are called "Constitutional rights."

Gosh! What fascist traits you have sir.
It seems that police training in the US is not quite what it should be.

I am reviewing my forthcoming trip to do business in the USA. And I shall be seeking assurance from the US ambassador that your attitude sir, is not a typical one. Do you mind if I use your comments as proof of my concerns?

Once again here's "Johnny" with the usual.. "Cops Can Do NO Wrong!" song. Of course we didn't expect anything else but that to be said by him.

Rail Car Fan

STFU Johnny Troll. Do you even OWN a camera?

It's rhetorical so don't answer. Jesus, what a looser.

Tell me something, "Johnny Law" ... why are cops exempt from the traffic laws? Why do they get to tailgate for miles on end (and don't tell me they don't - I've had cops riding 3 or 4 feet off my bumper at 65mph on I95 more times than I can count.)

Seems to me the reckless endangerment is that behavior. What sane rational woman, alone on a dark road at night, would not be frightened by such behavior by some stranger and eventually do something "erratic" as a result?

*crickets*

I guess even "Johnny Law" can't rationalize this question away.

A random question about police breaking traffic laws? Yeah you really have me stumped there.

You have to speed to be able to catch up with speeders. You have to get close to a vehicle to be able to read a license plate at night in order to put it out over the radio. You sometimes have to run red lights when a drunk blows one in front of you.

Any other meaningless questions?

And of course law enforcement officers never violate traffic laws except when pursuing those believed to be breaking the law, right?

It's not a "random question" because in this case the ranger tailgated her for miles on end with his high-beams on.

And your answer is a total crock. I have no trouble at all reading every licence plate on the road from several car lengths away, even at night. And I certainly don't need several miles of driving to do it. If your vision is that bad you have absolutely no business being a cop, or even driving on the roads at all.

What's really going on her - and you damn well know it - is that cops drive in this intimidating fashion in the hopes of frightening people into doing something wrong so they can pad their ticket count.

Tell me "Johnny Law" - would you want your mother treated this way? Would you treat her this way yourself? Are you so lacking in compassion that you have no ability to understand the effect such tactics have on entirely innocent people? Are you a sociopath, perhaps?

I do not think you just quite get it old chap do you?
This is not just about a traffic stop. It is much more.
In the UK we hold with great respect the wisdom and blood of the founding Fathers of who scribed your constitution. And yes, we're also a little jealous of such a noble document and all it's amendments. You, my kind Sir are a traitor to what project America is all about. Shame on you.

There are always those whackjobs who insist on going all "Lord of the Flies" on a good thing.

This story sounds true. I was driving early in the morning in Utah south of Salt Lake with my cruse just under the limit and a COP drove up to my blind spot and just hung out there, after a few minutes I just started slowing down I hate being put into dangerous situations, he just kept in my rear blind spot and I kept slowing down until I was about 45 my next move was going to pull over this guy was crazy then he sped by and pointed at me like I was doing something wrong.

I have learned two things, many COPs are just stupid and reckless, and the new culture supports it.

Just another thug with a badge.

Dug

COP's, Americas Most Wanted and other's have been filming arrest's for year's. Cop's can't have it both ways. I would say letting it happen this long would set a precident as to what is an acceptable expectation of privacy for police in today's society.

joe

johny until you walk on water your not god just an a** hole in a blue suit and with some serious authority issues. go buy another blowup girlfriend and amuse yourself at home when your mother is not there.HAHAHAHAHA
your IQ just went to a 89 score

Reminds me of the case of the Canadian writer Peter Watts
(rifters.com)busted for not getting back into his car fast enough when trying to EXIT the USSA into Canada.
A felony charge.
The jurors convicted him, but complained they felt they
had to because the way the stupid law is written.
On the bright side, he became a folk hero in this process like the Japanese lady who grabbed the TSA
tit.

Post new comment

Pixiq on Facebook

Join the 9996 Pixiq fans on Facebook

Share

  • Share

Subscribe

Get weekly updates from Pixiq. Short, sweet, and always interesting.