Another citizen complains about Miami Beach police
It is very late. Or very early. Depending on how much sleep you got.
I’ve been covering the Winter Music Conference for Miami Beach 411 and I can’t complain. It’s taking place mostly on Miami Beach.
Coincidentally, a Photography is Not a Crime reader had a bad experience with Miami Beach police tonight. That shouldn’t be surprising considering what we know of the department.
Here is the entire cut and paste of an email I received less than an hour ago. Photos will be posted soon. There’s nothing telling in them.
On March 25, 2010, at approximately 2:55 AM CST, two police officers driving a white Dodge Avenger took a left turn into the Sagamore Hotel on Collins Ave, Miami Beach, FL. The officers executed a sharp, fast left turn and cut off an individual who was eating a pizza. Unable to react to the officers’ sudden movements, the individual ran into the police vehicle’s passenger side. A police officer with dark, short hair with side burns, ran out of the vehicle, ran up to the individual, and said, “What do you think you’re doing you mother fucker. We’re trying to do something here. I will bust your fucking teeth out. Why don’t you drink some more you fucking drunk.” At which point, I pulled out my cellular phone and told the officer I was videotaping him and the police officer left the individual alone and returned to his business. I called 911 and told the operator what happened. The operator recorded the time, location, license plate number of the police vehicle, and description of the incident. She asked me if the individual would like to press charges and I said that he ran away for fear of being physically assaulting by a verbally threatening police officer. I gave the operator my phone number and name and she said that a police sergeant would contact me tomorrow. I went back to my hotel room, grabbed my camera, and returned to the scene to photograph the police officers involved. The Caucasian police officer blocked the license plate number so I couldn’t photograph it. The dark haired police officer was sitting in the passenger seat writing something. Upon seeing me photograph him, he said: “A lot of good that will do you, you mother fucking piece of shit.” I walked away and took more pictures and one of them said: “Keep taking pictures you potbellied mother fucker, why don’t you try doing some sit ups you piece of shit.” I left and returned to my hotel room.
The outcome of this incident will obviously be in the police officers’ favor. It is their word against ours and I’m sure some they will retell a story very different from mine. I don’t expect any justice in this matter. I just hope that the police officers involved will recognize that what they did was inappropriate for an officer of the peace and realize that there are vigilant citizens on the streets with the technology to record misconduct. My vacation to Miami Beach, FL was safe and uneventful until I witnessed police officers engaging in threatening, unprofessional behavior to innocent bystanders. While I understand that the police have to put up with so much, it is important to remember that in this country EVERYONE is innocent until proven guilty and we should be able to walk the streets without fear of assault from the very police officers who are suppose to be insuring our safety. When and if I return to Miami Beach, I will be sure to travel in groups and with cameras to protect myself from police misconduct. It is unfortunate that I am more afraid of the police than anything or anyone else on Miami Beach. I share this incident to educate America and urge people to both respect police officers and keep them accountable for their actions. It is important for us to share stories of police abuse in order keep the public aware. I encourage everyone involved in such incidents to report, record details, and photograph the officers involved. Hopefully, when the officers involved see their faces, they will be reminded of the public they swore to protect.
P.S. I received a voicemail on my phone March 25, 2010 at 3:52 AM from a “Sergeant Young.” The message simply said: “This is Sergeant Young, Miami Beach Police calling you back,” and hung up. He left no return phone number of instructions.
Can you fix the focus on a blurry photo after the fact?
The birth of Mirrorless Cameras
Choosing your first dSLR camera
New York City can be beautiful!
The Fujifilm Finepix X10, A Review
Choosing the Right Light Stand
Photojojo iPhone Telephoto Lens review — AudioCast
My week with Q
How To Become A Successful Photographer
"When the Wind Stopped" — poem with 4 photos
Tips for Textures
Butterflies in Motion
Cast aways - saving those photographic memories
One Man Show: My 25 Years With Digital Photography
Studio, Flash, & Available Light — Three Books Reviewed
Portrait styling: dangerous pairings
Adobe Photoshop CS6 Product Managers Interview Audiocast
A gift of flowers: unfold your senses
On Set of "Love & Robots" the Film
Ilford Galerie Gold Fibre Silk Inkjet Paper — Audiocast











Planning “National Geographic” style photo travel
Wilderness Travel 1 Rainforests – Essential Gear
Backlighting Basics
A Brief History Of Light & Photography: Part 3 of 3
A Brief History Of Light & Photography: Part 2 Of 3
What Moves You?
FIGURES IN MOTION: Decades of Evolving Personal Imagery in Photography, Part 7
Lomography Store, Austin, Texas — GALLERY
GALLERY — Up to $1,000 Reward for Cattle Rustlers
Taking your Portraiture Higher
The "Bible" of Time-Lapse Photography
Interview with Harold Davis — Closeup Maestro of Flowers & Water Drops
Interview with Steve Caplin — Photoshop Digital Artist, Commercial Illustrator, & Author
Easy technique to select, edit and sequence keywords for web
How much should you charge for a photograph?























Comments
Remember, there are always three sides to every story. His, the officer’s, and the truth.
The officers must have been having a tough day. The dog must have crapped on the floor before they left for work. They had a disagreement with thier wife. They are under a lot of stress. What other excuses can we give them for thier behaviour. If someone in any other stressful job behaved that way towards thier customers they’d be fired. I’m sure there are plenty of people that want that Miami Beach officers job.
Actually in a town like Miami Beach the cops get away with way more then in a normal town. There aren’t that many full time residents. If hey harass someone that’s visiting chances are the visitor isn’t going to complain and if it’s a visitor complaining there isn’t much the department is going to do because most visitors won’t have any political pull in that town.
Duane Kerzic´s last blog ..2010-03-09 Yahoo Hard At Work
Moto said..
“Remember, there are always three sides to every story. His, the officer’s, and the truth.”
NOT if you talk to “Johnny Law”. As far as he’s concerned the first (victim’s) and the last (truth) sides don’t count.
After all.. Cop’s can do NO wrong.
Rail Car Fan
All bitching aside, I’d like to hear Miami Dade’s official response to this.
Think maybe a request for a statement would result in any?
Carlos, you make a great case for cops screwing with photographers, but what about cops lying, misstating facts, fabricating evidence, coercing witnesses, perjuring themselves under oath, etc… How can we worry about photographers civil rights when we have much worse and far more serious violations of our civil rights going on every day? Why hasn’t someone drawn attention to what goes on day in and day out with the cops down here?
At worse, you were facing misdemeanor charges when the cops screwed with you the first time, what about some of the cases I’ve been writing about where the cops targeted innocent people, arrested them on bullshit cases that they made up then had them sitting in jail to make $500,000 bail just so they could make a headline and help secure federal funding for their task forces?
The Straw Buyer´s last blog ..Detective Baluja and ASA Kostrzewski deliver more fail….
To be honest, I’d prefer that you not do the “calling out” on JL. He has his stance and it is not always wrong. (Butt Monkey coming) However, given that he thought going to the police report on an excessive force accusation would give him the “facts”, rather than a possibly biased and false reporting of the incident in order to save butt is indicative of why PDs should not police themselves, as well as a lack of depth on his part, because they begin with a bias towards the officer rather than a neutral stance.
It takes a greater strength to write a permanent truthful report that would get a you into trouble or fired than to face a transient physically violent situation. The assumption that simply because police deal with physical violence makes them automatically strong on integrity is more than fallacious, it ignores millennia of human truth. Unfortunately, a degree in “Criminal Justice” doesn’t seem to make that obvious.
As an aside, I’m beginning to believe that military personnel should be banned from police jobs for 5 to 10 years after the honorable discharge. The “us v. them” mentality seems to carry over too much. I’ve been in the military and saw too much of it, even in the USCG. It’s such an incredibly stupid, brain-dead, tribal mentality unless you are truly at war. Real war like Iwo Jima or Okinawa. Fallujah doesn’t qualify. If you can’t understand the difference, just ask, it has nothing to do with gunfire (hint: Okinawa and Iwo Jima were not “liberation”; France was, Iraq is even if Carlos disagrees, it has to do with stance). And, no, the “Drug War” doesn’t qualify either.
Unfortunately this happen a lot in Miami Beach, I went to the station to get information and fill out a report, an officer name Gracia from the K9 unit, was in the clerk, without stop drink his coffee, he didn’t let me talk and was very, very, very rude……I just hope his dog be more polite than him…..But the way I was so uncomfortable with the situation, that I said thank you and left without any help, that is the Miami Beach police department today a hang job for low educated people, but I make clear there are some good officer at the Miami Beach police also……The thing that I regret is that I was without my camera....
all the beach cop was doing was trying to help the gentleman stay healthy but suggesting he do sit-ups…and sarcastically suggesting that he not drink anymore so he wouldnt get sick…part of law enforcement is caring for your public!
‘Roid rage??
Even up here in Canuckistan the filth are getting into the “let’s beat the shit out of someone because we wear a badge made out of tin,” act, shameful
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mnwi6wO03As
http://www.calgaryherald.com/news/Victoria+police+chief+responds+kicking...
Jody´s last blog ..Bill Gates, Toshiba in early talks on nuclear reactor
You think Miami is bad, go up to Ocala/Marion County, the biggest industry
of that god-forsaken place is locking people up.
Florida…. come on vacation, leave on Probation.
BTW This website keeps getting slower and slower.
Situps can’t do much for a potbelly. Cardio is best!
Guy Freeman´s last blog ..Goatse Orange
Well, no one likes getting tapped in the rear especially by a guy eating a slice
Guy Freeman´s last blog ..Goatse Orange
Allow me to get that straw man for you… Fallujah, for the people that were there, was as real as war is ever going to be in this century.
Make no mistake, the people that stormed the cities in Iraq in the early to mid 2000s are suffering for it, a lot worse for the wear.
I had not heard of officer of the peace before.
The categories I know of are, 1 Peace Officer, 2 Law Enforcement Officer, 3 Government Agent,
and 4 Secret Policeman.
It is too long for this comment to discuss these categories, suffice it to say that 1 is the only sort you want to deal with.
Officers in article are 2 or 3.
Presently there is certainly good deal to know regarding this. We think you created great points additionally.
Post new comment