Flash (Pet Peeves I)

What Not to do with Flash

It's just a law of physics.  Light drops off by the square of the distance. 

What the heck does that mean?  Am I peeved about physical laws?  Not really.  What I'm peeved by is this:

Were you ever in a stadium with thousands of fans, and most of them are a quarter of a mile from the action and some great thing happens on the field and flashes pop all over the place?  I've been with friends who've done it, and tried to explain that the tiny flash on their p/s or even their dslr is just not going to make it to the pitcher's mound.

Or you're in a crowd, New Years Eve, and the subject that you want to capture is eight city blocks away, and you're shooting with a not-so-smart phone or any camera.  And midnight hits and flashes go off like fireworks.

New Years Eve and Flash

Well, I don't care if you've got a powerful off-camera flash, it's just not going to do anything for you if you're ten blocks away.

In fact, the odds are that you'll overlight the people in the foreground.  But anyway, the rule is very simple.  Let's say that you can properly expose an object with your flash on high power at 10 feet, f2.8 and 1/60th of a second.  If you double the distance, and move to 20 feet, you'll need to open up two stops.  If you double the distance again, you'll need to open up another two stops.

The automatic everything camera doesn't care much about this, but sees that it's dark, maybe it makes itself more sensitive, but the tiny flash is just not going to reach ten blocks. 

On the other hand, when you are in a small room with your friends and take their picture and the flash is the overwhelming light you will get all sorts of problems.  You may have had enough light to shoot without flash.

Anyway - that's my pet peeve for the day.  I ended up shooting these shots by putting them on a monopod and holding it above everyone's head.

New Years Eve

If my flash had fired, I wouldn't have had the effect of all the LCD lights.  I realize that not everyone is going to bring a monopod with them but at least experimenting with what (if anything) you can get at night if you set the ASA as high as it can go, and maybe find something to steady the camera on.  Just don't expect your flash to illuminate Times Square (already bright enough) with flash from n number of blocks away.  And if you can - wow.  That's a heck of a flash.

Comments

right.... the thing is with those P+S cameras, sometimes you have to trick it to get a faster shutter speed. (i don't think anyone using these is thinking about that though)

I totally agree. All my cameras, compact, bridge and DSLR are set to flash OFF as standard to avoid this embarrassing phenomenon. I sometimes think people do it on purpose at sports events as a kind of "I am here" indication, a bit like the old "waving the lighter" thing at rock concerts. I'd always up the ISO rather than switch on on-camera flash. Give me digital noise over blown out foregrounds anytime.

Eric Reichbaum
Pixiq Expert

Last year I saw a tourist in Union Square in New York with a Nikon D700 taking a photo of a building at least 300 feet away and his built in flash popped up and went off, in broad daylight. Gotta love when people buy toys they don't know how to use just because they can afford it haha.

Dave Beckerman
Pixiq Expert

How about a small flash for smart phones (the new P/S) that can be attached, swiveled, off to the side etc.

How about a flash on a p/s that can simply be swiveled up so that you can bounce it from the ceiling and not blow people away with it?

How about a camera that in simple mode won't use the flash unless it's needed... hmmm... that one might be hard to computerize.

But they now have cameras for recognizing human faces. If you can't find a human face to focus on... that's another one I don't get.

If nothing else, think of all the energy that's wasted when everyone at the superbowl takes a flash shot that has no chance of reaching the field.

I just see flash ruining shots, or being used for no reason, over and over.

Eric, I was at the top of the rock at night, filled with tourists, various cameras - everyone using their flash to photograph the New York skyline. It's just crazy.

It's good to see someone write about this. My friends always look at me like I've grown a third eye when I point out that the poor sap in the cheap seats of a baseball stadium is simply wasting batter power when their flash goes off.

I had someone snarl "I'm taking a picture, moron!" once when I asked why his flash went off at a football game.

He was using film. There was no talking to him. At least with a digital these days, they sometimes can be talked to about it after their folly becomes clear.

Post new comment

Pixiq on Facebook

Join the 10132 Pixiq fans on Facebook

Share

  • Share

Subscribe

Get weekly updates from Pixiq. Short, sweet, and always interesting.