Miami Beach police accused of wrongly arresting gay men (and photographers)


It used to be that the Miami Police Department was the most notorious law enforcement agency in South Florida.

But that was before the Miami Beach Police Department started giving it a run for its money.

Besides shooting and killing two unarmed suspects in a span of four days last year (by the same officer, nonetheless) and building a reputation for racial profiling and unlawful arrests on Memorial Day Weekend, the Miami Beach Police Department is now accused of beating and wrongly arresting gay men.

In other words, they are being accused of hate crimes.

The ACLU on Wednesday announced its intent to sue the police department, citing an incident involving Harold Strickland, a gay man who called 911 last year to report two officers beating and kicking a gay man who lay handcuffed on the ground.

Strickland was assaulted and arrested himself in an incident that was recorded on a 911 dispatch tape.

Naturally, the police report contradicts the events that were recorded.

Officers Frankly Forte and Elliot Hazzi claimed Strickland was breaking into cars and took off running when they approached him. The recording proves that Strickland was cooperative with police.

Besides, when was the last time you heard of a car thief dialing 911 in the midst of a crime spree to report police brutality?

In its letter to Miami Beach Mayor Matti Bower, the ACLU also brings up the excessive arrests that occur every Memorial Day Weekend when throngs of young black people descend upon Miami Beach for the annual hip hop fest.

They are accused of arresting people for photographing incidents of police misconduct and seizing their memory cards and cameras.

If you remember, I was one of the photographers arrested by Miami Beach police last Memorial Day Weekend. This is from the ACLU press release.

MBPD officers also have an alarming history of arresting individuals, particularly African-American men and women, who witness police misconduct. During Urban Beach Week over Memorial Day weekend, the ACLU of Florida received reports that MBPD officers threatened and then arrested people of color who observed and photographed officers’ unlawful arrests. MBPD officers forcibly seized SIM cards from observers’ cell phones after they used their cell phone cameras to document incidents of police misconduct.

Besides the Memorial Day Weekend Blitzkrieg, the ACLU says there is an ongoing pattern of harassment against gay men, which might be surprising to some considering that South Beach has long been considered a mecca for homosexuals.

The announcement of the lawsuit comes on the heels of a Miami New Times article that described Miami Beach as one of the most dangerous places in Florida for homosexuals to live.

The article prompted criticisms from Miami Herald gay issues reporter Steve Rothaus and Miami Beach’s gay publication, Wire Magazine as being exaggerated and sensationalized with both publications stating the numbers cited in the New Times’ article were misleading.

But if it is true that the Miami Beach Police Department has an ongoing systematic pattern of unlawfully beating and arresting gay men, then it’s a sure bet those numbers were understated.

Comments

Anonymous
Anonymous

I really hope that the standards of justice that apply to a private citizen will apply to a cop that commits a hate crime. WTF? Cops are illegally confiscating SIM cards, from cell phones and memory cards from cameras? Where is the mainstream media on this?
Rob´s last blog ..San Diego Trolley Guards Prohibit Photography

I prefer to be true to myself, even at the hazard of incurring the ridicule of others, rather than to be false, and to incur my own abhorrence well said by Frederick.
curt
Nike Red Shoe

Anonymous
Anonymous

I’m glad to see the ACLU get this into court where it belongs. The Miami Beach PD’s consistent disregard for civil rights has turned into an epoch game of `whack a mole` with all of the obvious cases that have been individually addressed over the last few years.

I hope this results in better hiring selection and training. What I looked for and can’t find (Carlos, you may have this already) is the annual budget spent on law enforcement. I’m almost willing to bet its scary low.

This behavior is just too consistent to NOT point to a common underlying cause.
Tim Post´s last blog ..US National Archives Joins Flickr Commons

Anonymous
Anonymous

What the hell has happened to law enforcement? Was it always this bad and we just didn’t notice?

Anonymous
Anonymous

Tim I’m not sure what you mean by the budget being scary low. I can tell you that most police contrary to what they say are paid rather well for the service (beatings, muggings, harassment, theft, killings) they provide.

Here are the salaries in Fayetteville, NC.
http://police.ci.fayetteville.nc.us/recsalarybenefits.aspx
This does not include the overtime, and separate pay they receive for events like concerts, or high-school ball games.

This is for high-school, or GED education.

Police Officer Step Plan
Effective July, 2008
Full Year(s) of Service Base Salary % Increase
Starting $33,813
1 $35,166
2 $36,572
3 $38,035
4 $39,937
5 $41,934
6 $44,030
7 $45,792
8 $47,623
9 $49,528
10 $51,509
11 $53,570
12 $55,712
13 $57,941

Here is a view of the city statistics notice the median income is well below what the cops are being being paid in the first link.
http://www.city-data.com/city/Fayetteville-North-Carolina.html

Estimated median household income in 2008: $44,086 (it was $36,287 in 2000)
Fayetteville: $44,086
North Carolina: $46,549

Estimated per capita income in 2008: $24,559

I’ll let you find your own demographics for other cities, but I’ll bet the police are almost always paid above the average citizen in any locality.

I’d be even more willing to bet you would have a hell of a time finding this level of salary for education levels in many other fields.

Anonymous
Anonymous

Good thing I am not gay…….is what most will say.

Hopefully, they will be prosecuted to the same level of law as anyone else would be. However, we have seen time and again that this will not be the case. Sad.
mepsipax´s last blog ..Hump Day hate

Anonymous
Anonymous

Awareness is an artifact of the last few years, even though the information has been available to anyone with an IP address for much longer.

There are many police departments, some of them have major issues, Miami Beach PD appears to be one of them. That doesn’t mean that Ashtebulah, Ohio has the same issues.

Miami Beach has some interesting logistics to deal with – people flock there from all over the world several times a year to do nothing but get drunk and party.

Obviously, they are not well equipped to handle this and that has to be fixed.
Tim Post´s last blog ..US National Archives Joins Flickr Commons

Anonymous
Anonymous

Its not just what they are paid, its how much money is invested in training and supervising them. Miami Beach is different, people from all over the world flock there several times a year to get very drunk and party. That calls for a different approach to training, policing, administration and oversight.

I don’t care if you are paying each officer $100k yearly, if you invested only hundreds in their training, well …

When I said budget, I meant the whole picture, not just officer salaries. Thanks for pointing that out, I should have been a bit more specific.
Tim Post´s last blog ..US National Archives Joins Flickr Commons

Anonymous
Anonymous

What’s worse than these cops though are the biased and corrupt state attorneys/prosecutors that cover up their misdeeds through intimidation and coercion.

Anonymous
Anonymous

ROB: i was thinking the same when i saw some of what the LEO’s were doing. the media cant say that they dont know this is going on, although that is what they may attempt to claim! Coverup, naw cant make that claim yet, but i think its a tad closer to being a possibility then i would prefer. this hate crime thing may bring it to another level., who knows. I was arrested almost a year ago now, and the LEO’s still have my stuff, well what they say was evidence, the division chief, claims that there is still a chance they may refile some of the charges, i say he is full of {St}! Not sure what William Riley/division chief MIAMIBEACH/police, meant by that but I am sure he will make sure that justice is had by all!

Anonymous
Anonymous

Hopefully the ACLU is successful with this case. As I believe to have heard, they haven’t been having the best track record in Florida, so let’s hope for the best. Another prejudiced wrong doing by the Miami police, how incredibly not surprising .
Jordan´s last blog ..Discount Tire Stores

Post new comment

Pixiq on Facebook

Join the 10131 Pixiq fans on Facebook

Share

  • Share

Subscribe

Get weekly updates from Pixiq. Short, sweet, and always interesting.