Editor sues Newark police after getting arrested over photographs
Update: The photographer’s name is Geraldo Carlos. As of today, he has not been deported.
Carlos Miller
What is it they teach these officers in the police academy anyway?
Obviously not basic First Amendment rights because these arrests continue to happen.
But this case will probably get all the Constitution-quoting xenophobes to side with police because the photographer was an illegal immigrant.
Never mind the fact that the photographer was the one who got police involved in the first place by reporting a body he had come across to his editor, who did what any normal person would do, and called police.
However, when police arrived, they handcuffed Brazilian Voice editor Roberto Lima to a bench until he agreed to hand over the photos that his photographer took, according to his federal lawsuit.
“I offered Newark police the original photographs as long as I could keep copies, but they handcuffed me to a bench until I agreed to give them all copies and originals,” Lima said in a statement. “They ordered me not to publish the pictures, but freedom of the press means that it’s my choice, not the Newark Police Department’s.”
The Associated Press reporter, Jeffrey Gold, neglected to mention whether or not the photographer was also handcuffed.
But he was an illegal immigrant from Portugal so maybe he has no rights.
Or maybe he does.
The lawsuit comes about two months after state Attorney General Anne Milgram said Deputy Chief Samuel DeMaio should be disciplined for questioning Lima and the photographer about their immigration status.
This must have confused DeMaio because it was only a few months earlier that Milgram ordered police to notify federal authorities when they believe a suspect is in the country illegally. However, this was only meant for suspects arrested for “indictable offenses or drunken driving.”
In other words, even Milgram is aware that photography is not an indictable offense.
The policy was prompted after a suspect in the slayings of three college students in Newark was found to be an illegal immigrant who was free on bail on child rape charges when the young people were killed.
Because we all know that child rapists who are in this country legally are safe to walk our streets.
Fujifilm's X-Pro1, now M Mount friendly
Olympus' Micro Four Thirds 75mm prime
Can you fix the focus on a blurry photo after the fact?
The birth of Mirrorless Cameras
The Joy Of Winning A Photo Contest
Choosing your first dSLR camera
New York City can be beautiful!
Choosing the Right Light Stand
Photojojo iPhone Telephoto Lens review — AudioCast
My week with Q
How To Become A Successful Photographer
"When the Wind Stopped" — poem with 4 photos
Creating The New Family Portrait
Tips for Textures
Cast aways - saving those photographic memories
One Man Show: My 25 Years With Digital Photography
Studio, Flash, & Available Light — Three Books Reviewed
Portrait styling: dangerous pairings
Adobe Photoshop CS6 Product Managers Interview Audiocast
A gift of flowers: unfold your senses
On Set of "Love & Robots" the Film
No-Brainer Setup For A Digital Photo Frame Exhibit - Part 3











Planning “National Geographic” style photo travel
Wilderness Travel 1 Rainforests – Essential Gear
Backlighting Basics
What Moves You?
FIGURES IN MOTION: Decades of Evolving Personal Imagery in Photography, Part 7
Lomography Store, Austin, Texas — GALLERY
GALLERY — Up to $1,000 Reward for Cattle Rustlers
25% off on photography eBooks
eyePhone: The eBook for iPhone Photographers
Interview with Harold Davis — Closeup Maestro of Flowers & Water Drops
Interview with Steve Caplin — Photoshop Digital Artist, Commercial Illustrator, & Author
A Brief History Of Light & Photography: Part 3 of 3
A Brief History Of Light & Photography: Part 2 Of 3
Easy technique to select, edit and sequence keywords for web
How much should you charge for a photograph?

























Comments
It just seems like most of these police departments have not trained their officers with regard to this issue. Maybe a training (you could produce it) would be of benefit. Heck, don’t they have to sit through the 1/2 video on sexual harrassment?
Ms Calabaza,
I knew a guy in Arizona who created this consulting business where he would give seminars to police departments on how to deal with the media.
First Amendment and photography issues were part of it, but he focused overall on just general media relations, on how to maintain a civil relationship because many police departments fail at this.
A lot of them think they can just ignore the media, but they need the media to help them as well, like when they want the public to help them find a suspect or something.
So this guy in Arizona would get hired by different police departments around the country and he made good money doing that.
And it wasn’t hard to do at all because he was just stressing common sense that sometimes get lost when police and reporters interact.
I’ve actually thought of coming up with a similar type of service where I focus on First Amendment issues, but also on media relations overall.
But I can’t do anything until I get past my case.
Carlos,
over the years, I’ve learned that there’s a reason for everything in life. Even the crummy times. Try to look at this as a possible venture, after your case. It sure appears like law enforcement needs to address this problem.
Ms Calabaza,
I do believe everything will work out in a positive manner in the future, but right now, I would be lying if I said the arrest has not been a setback for me.
Post new comment