Rochester Police To Undergo Training After Retaliatory Incidents
The Rochester Police Chief acknowledged that his officers acted in a retaliatory fashion by issuing petty tickets to citizens supporting Emily Good, the woman who was arrested in May for videotaping a traffic stop from her front yard.
Actually, he didn’t quite the use the word retaliatory.
He called it “targeted enforcement activity,” which is cop talk for retaliatory.
He also said it was “unacceptable” and “inappropriate” and promised that those tickets would be voided, according to 13WHAM, Rochester’s ABC affiliate.
And he mentioned that the commander overseeing those officers was replaced, but wouldn’t give any more details on internal disciplinary actions.
He also denounced Good’s arrest by saying it was merely a “training issue” that needs to be resolved.
The truth is, both incidents were retaliatory.
The first incident was retaliatory against a woman who insisted on video recording a traffic stop from her front yard, even after the cop ordered her inside.
And the second incident was retaliatory against citizens who dared take a stand against the first incident.
The National Press Photographers Association played a strong role in new training procedures for the department.
Mickey Osterreicher, general counsel for the NPPA, sent the following statement to Photography is Not a Crime:
"NPPA is pleased that the Rochester police have announced new training for its officers regarding obstruction charges. I met with the chief earlier this week and was asked to review their policies and procedures regarding photography by members of the press and public. NPPA looks forward to working with them as we have with other police agencies around the country. We are glad that they have taken a more enlightened approach to this issue and look forward to their implementing our recommendations. As with any policies, the key will be continuing training and enforcement should those procedures be violated."
Good, who was arrested in May, has since filed a lawsuit.
Less than a week after the video went viral, Rochester citizens gathered in a community meeting to discuss police accountability when four cops pulled up outside and started issuing parking tickets, using a little pink ruler to determine if they had parked more than 12 inches from the curb.
The incident was recorded in the above video by Davy Vara, a longtime video activist whom I had the pleasure of meeting over the summer when he was visiting Miami.

Vara also recorded the following video in which a Rochester cop was parked more than 12 inches from the curb, but was not cited.
Fujifilm's X-Pro1, now M Mount friendly
Olympus' Micro Four Thirds 75mm prime
Can you fix the focus on a blurry photo after the fact?
The birth of Mirrorless Cameras
The Joy Of Winning A Photo Contest
Choosing your first dSLR camera
New York City can be beautiful!
Choosing the Right Light Stand
Photojojo iPhone Telephoto Lens review — AudioCast
My week with Q
How To Become A Successful Photographer
"When the Wind Stopped" — poem with 4 photos
Creating The New Family Portrait
Tips for Textures
Cast aways - saving those photographic memories
One Man Show: My 25 Years With Digital Photography
Studio, Flash, & Available Light — Three Books Reviewed
Portrait styling: dangerous pairings
Adobe Photoshop CS6 Product Managers Interview Audiocast
A gift of flowers: unfold your senses
On Set of "Love & Robots" the Film
No-Brainer Setup For A Digital Photo Frame Exhibit - Part 3











San Diego 7 photo gallery — Just Be Love All Stay Cool
Planning “National Geographic” style photo travel
Wilderness Travel 1 Rainforests – Essential Gear
Backlighting Basics
What Moves You?
FIGURES IN MOTION: Decades of Evolving Personal Imagery in Photography, Part 7
Lomography Store, Austin, Texas — GALLERY
GALLERY — Up to $1,000 Reward for Cattle Rustlers
25% off on photography eBooks
eyePhone: The eBook for iPhone Photographers
Interview with Harold Davis — Closeup Maestro of Flowers & Water Drops
Interview with Steve Caplin — Photoshop Digital Artist, Commercial Illustrator, & Author
A Brief History Of Light & Photography: Part 3 of 3
A Brief History Of Light & Photography: Part 2 Of 3
Easy technique to select, edit and sequence keywords for web
How much should you charge for a photograph?
































Comments
Bah. He just caved to political pressure. Illegal parking is illegal parking. So if someone makes a complaint on an officer, that means they can break the law without fear of having enforcement action taken?
I remember when I worked street narcotics there was a little female drug dealer who worked the corners in my area. My team and I arrested her and she made some bogus complaint about it. When Internal Affairs gave us notice about the investigation, they cautioned us to stay away from her.
My sarge was there and luckily he was not afraid of standing up to the brass. He told the IA investigator that if the dealer was in my area and breaking the law, he fully expected me to take enforcement action against her. The IA guy looked shocked but said that he understood.
Good thing I didn't have the chain of command in Rochester huh?
As long as they're going to crack down on illegal parking, they should start by citing themselves.
Here is another video shot by Davy Vara.
http://www.youtube.com/user/davyvtv#p/u/8/PHXTzkSBnEE
Couldn't find a way to submit a link to you, but thought you'd be interested in this: http://www.clickorlando.com/news/29019754/detail.html
Short version: Cops claim a man in a truck gunned the engine to ram them, they shoot him (almost fatally) in self-defense... but a security camera tells a different story.
Hopefully you don't work in a place where it takes four patrol officers to issue four parking tickets.
How many tickets can you write at one time? Once you start criticizing how many officers showed up on scene, I know you are grasping at straws.
Even when the cops say they are wrong they aren't wrong. Because Johnny Troll says so.
Now you seem to be on the same page. Good deal. Took you long enough.
Hey hero, why don't you reveal your true identity instead of hiding behind your pseudonym?
Harry Callahan. I'm an inspector with the San Francisco PD.
You're a coward.
Do you feel lucky punk?
That is pretty smug Dirty Harry...
JL, you are pathetic.
Then again JL why ONLY this street? This is as many have said time and time again is not a question of it being illegal it's a question of ONLY these people being punished for it.
Is ignoring something that many people do and just enforcing it on people that piss you off really the kind of cop you are or are you fair and cite everyone?
How do you know there were parking violations on the other streets? Wasn't this some gathering with people coming in from outside the neighborhood?
I don't cite everyone. No cop does. It depends on the circumstances.
I thought you were undercover narc officer? It seems like someone in that position would be over issuing petty citations for parking, possession etc...
I used to be. Now I supervise a patrol shift. "Petty" citations are actually very important quality of life issues for neighborhoods.
And also for generating revenue an keeping the entire "justice" system functioning.
Continually writing petty citation tickets to homeless people for open containers (which never get paid and ultimately turn into warrants) is not real policing. Nor is it truly accomplishing anything except for keeping yourselves employed on the taxpayers' hard earned money.
Unlike what you think of yourself, you're not a hero, but rather the biggest threat to civil society in the United States.
"Unlike what you think of yourself, you're not a hero, but rather the biggest threat to civil society in the United States."
I guess all those people that come up to me to shake my hand and thank me for the job I do are just sheep huh?
wow fake career, fake gun, fake badge, fake tough as nails superior, fake drug dealers, fake perps, fake lawyers for the fake perps . . . now Johnny Law has fake fans as well.
Do you have a fake siren that you wail in your cool fake car?
LOL yeah I'm typing this on my fake computer as well.
I would to my fake shift tonight my fake schedule gives me three days off my fake job. I may go for a run with my fake dog later and have a fake beer afterwards.
Gee this is fun!
"How do you know there were parking violations on the other streets? Wasn't this some gathering with people coming in from outside the neighborhood?"
I love you Johnny Law and I'm glad you're on this site to provide some often enlightening perspective from the other side, but you are really burying your head in the sand on this one.
It's OK to admit that cops are humans who sometimes let their emotions get the better of them and stick up for their own to a fault. That doesn't make all cops bad people.
While I generally agree that illegal parking is illegal parking.. Thats not much of an argument. However when enforcement appears to be designed to hassle those standing up to police it becomes a problem. Selective enforcement against those opposing them give the appearance that "you should just do as you are told".
You must realized this JL, to most people this looks like intimidation in response to people standing up against a truly bone headed action by police. Political or not, this is the stuff that turns people against the police and achieves NOTHING positive. They'd already screwed the pooch on the Good woman, they only dug themselves a deeper hole by stepping up enforcement against those in opposition to them.
Now using your example of the dealer lady, if you made it a point to ticket/arrest her for anything that might be interpreted as illegal then yeah, you would probably have been acting improperly and retaliatory. If you ran across her and she was breaking the law then probably not.
If they go with the mindset to hassle these people then they were in the wrong. That isn't in your job description.
"My sarge was there and luckily he was not afraid of standing up to the brass."
So he didn't call you and your new partner into his office? Scream at you that he just got off the phone with the Mayor? Comment about the missing chunk out of his ass and pull you off the case? Threaten you with suspension if you go anywhere near that corner again? And he should take the damages caused by your crazy car chase out of your pay???
Crazy.
I present Johnny Troll's little female drug dealer.
hmmm...
that's one of the funniest posts I've read in a while, spot on. I was going to say all he is missing is a partner who is 3 days from retirement and getting too old for this sh*t . . .
Darn it. I forgot that part. Time for a re-write! We'll need a catch phrase too...
"He stands up to the brass, but on the internet he's an ass . . . he is . . . Johnny Law! promoting bad police work one website at a time . . . "
Made me think of one of my favorite movies. I think you may have watched this scene too much.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W0ZMzlQJyYY&feature=related
SLAAAAAAAAAATERRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!
This is bullshit. You're just trying to obfuscate the real issue here: A person, within their rights ( and possibly even doing a DUTY ) took video of a cop who couldn't take the heat. The rest of the cop mob retaliated in a mean and petty fashion, as cops do - en masse- and got caught.
Training won't work, because the root is poisoned. Pull the tree out and start over.
Training? " Here's a train-get the fuck on it".
Total transparency is how it should work. If you don't like being videoed, get another job, cause you work for us, and we have the right to record what you do. End of story.
JL, The police work 'for the people'. Aquiessing to public demands is part of the job description. The police do not function above, apart, or separate from the people they serve, or for that matter, the law.
"Aquiessing to public demands is part of the job description."
Please explain that sentence further. So if I am taking some type of enforcement action and members of the public start complaining, should I get in my car and slink away?
The job description is to enforce the laws. The politicians sway with the public demands. It should not affect us other than to add resources to illegal activity that is brought to our attention such as a rash of break-ins or an area with a large number of speeders.
"Law enforcement" bowing to community pressure:
http://www.oregonlive.com/opinion/index.ssf/2010/05/in_chicago_another_s...
Several other stories that don't explicitly acknowledge the pressure from the community against enforcement of illegal laws (remember 'ol Norton vs Shelby County); in any case, the "laws" were not "enforced":
http://www.falfiles.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2907687
http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2010-06-03/news/ct-met-intruder-shoot...
To answer your question directly, if you are engaged in illegal activity and bystanders call you on it, yes, you should certainly cease your illegal activity and attempt to slink away.
"Good thing I didn't have the chain of command in Rochester huh?"
No, but it is a good thing that this story is not about you.
Bait and switch, change the focus from the blatant and despicable illegal arrest of Emily Good, and then pretend that the men who were issuing the tickets were not doing so in retaliation. The adults in the room know exactly what happened and the adults in the room including the brass have taken a ethical and moral stance.
The officer might have been sticking to the letter of the law,But people Ethical and decent people know that the law is MORE then that. The Police are supposed to be a part of a community,working with the people who employ them. NOT acting like stooges.
When you defend the indefensible, you reveal something about yourself.
The only training these clown suits should get is on the french fryer at Burger King.
Only first, everyone who got a ticket should get a free opportunity to drive-stun the ex-officers' gonads.
She needed to call in the state police or the FBI for the cops' kicking in her door and ransacking her place. That burglary was another “targeted enforcement activity” that needs to be rectified.
Rochester Police Department: Taking on the mean streets - one pink ruler at a time.
Note that the regular authoritarian here thinks that four cops doing the job of one parking enforcement officer is an acceptable use of resources. Note that he ridiculously equates parking a few inches further from the curb than the allotted 12 with every other kind of law.
And, finally, note that he has no response to the blatant, clownish, and incompetent hypocrisy of the same department breaking the very same laws the authoritarian equates with all other laws.
His predictably reflexive shallowness is thoroughly entertaining.
Same Troll who thinks banging a chick on the hood of a cruiser in public is not against the law.
Have to give him credit though. His stories are getting better. Now he has a team that does drug busts and writes one parking ticket at a time.
http://www.policeone.com/investigations/articles/4302971-NM-cop-having-s...
Apparently he didn't commit a crime. Of course in your world, he did just because he is a cop.
Grow up sonny boy.
Nice to know you think so highly of your profession that you fail to realize this cop was highly inappropriate. Law enforcement should be held to a higher standard than the "not sworn not born" citizens, that includes refraining from public sex on department vehicles in public view, in uniform. If he was on duty, he should be fired. If someone actually witnessed it, they should be arrested as any civilian would be. I'm quite surprised they didn't try to charge the owner of the security camera with voyeurism or some other nonsense.
Johnny, if you continue to think lowly of your bothers and sisters in uniform, everyone else will too.
It could be argued a crime was committed by the chief.
Misappropriation of public funds for paying 12 officers to do the job of 1 or 2.
Highly inappropriate is not the same as illegal. Please check dictionary.com.
The officer will probably face some pretty severe internal discipline for this and that is fine with me. Would anyone care if this was a UPS driver?
Unlike the cop, the UPS driver would be fired and charged with a crime. But we all know how the law never applies to cops.
And as far as I know, exposing yourself and having sex in public IS a crime and will get you on the sex offender's list. That is, if you're not a cop protected by a hollow, tin badge.
Wasn't this in the corner of a parking lot in a facility with a fence around it?
That's not going to meet the criteria of having sex in public. He got fired though. Shouldn't you be crowing about that instead of crying that he didn't get the death penalty?
"Shouldn't you be crowing about that instead of crying that he didn't get the death penalty?"
I never said anything like that, nor would I ever since I do not support the death penalty in any case. But great job going off the deep end in a horrible attempt at trying to inaccurately label me as some non-sensical extremist.
Admittedly, I was extremely surprised that the officer was fired since police officers are rarely punished for their crimes. On the other hand, I was very happy to see him shown the door for his behavior. People like this man do not deserve a badge or any kind of authority over anyone. I do believe the officer should be charged with a crime though, since if this were a non-cop that would be the case.
So what's your real name?
Nice to know you think so highly of your profession that you fail to realize this cop was highly inappropriate. Law enforcement should be held to a higher standard than the "not sworn not born" citizens, that includes refraining from public sex on department vehicles in public view, in uniform. If he was on duty, he should be fired. If someone actually witnessed it, they should be arrested as any civilian would be. I'm quite surprised they didn't try to charge the owner of the security camera with voyeurism or some other nonsense.
Johnny, if you continue to think lowly of your bothers and sisters in uniform, everyone else will too.
Public indecency is a crime and so is exposing yourself. The fact that he was not charged means that his superiors covered up a crime. Fire the cop and fire the Chief.
Post new comment