Umbrella vs Beauty Dish

Selecting Lighting Tools

Yesterday I shot a beauty assignment with one of my favorite models.  I often use a profoto beauty dish for beauty assignments like this, but yesterday I decided to use a white umbrella with my profoto strobes instead.  The reason for switching from the beauty dish to the white umbrella was because the assignment called for me to photograph jewelry on the model.  While the beauty dish is one of my favorite lights for shooting beauty I didn't want the specular highlights on the jewelry so a softer main light was needed.  

Knowing the benefits and drawbacks of every lighting source  helps you make the best decisions on selecting the lighting for each job.  There is no one light that fits every situation and this is one of the reason why its so important to test your light and discover how each light looks under different conditions.  During your light testing phase you will learn about the quality of light and when to use different lighting tools to make better images.  

The image of the model washing her face was shot with the profoto white beauty dish which worked well in that situation.  The image of the model with the jewelry was created using the white umbrella and was better suited to shoot the  assignment because of its soft quality.

 

Always Dream Big!

 

Instructional videos:  www.Gallery.MatthewJordanSmith.com

Website:  www.MatthewJordanSmith.com

 

 

Comments

I wonder.. are you only using one light source and are you shooting through the umbrella or reflecting?

Matthew Jordan Smith
Pixiq Expert

Hi Bryan,

Thanks for the question. The umbrella is shot bouncing the light in the traditional manner and both images are with only one light source. I am a big believer of doing lighting tests and also mastering one light before adding other light sources. Thanks for the question and I hope this helped.

Matthew Jordan Smith

Post new comment

Pixiq on Facebook

Join the 10197 Pixiq fans on Facebook

Share

  • Share

Subscribe

Get weekly updates from Pixiq. Short, sweet, and always interesting.