Why didn’t anybody tell me all I needed to do was donate toys to charity?

Carlos Miller
Daniel Zuniga, the promising young prosecutor who was assigned to my case, was fired this week from the Miami-Dade State Attorney’s Office for participating in a “toys for case dismissal” agreement with Miami-Dade County Judge Karen Mills Francis – the judge presiding over my case.

Unfortunately, I was never informed of this philantropic set-up, for I would have gladly donated toys to charity in exchange for my case being dismissed.

But now that The Miami Herald broke the story, the odds are slim that I will be given the same opportunity as the countless others who had their criminal charges dropped after donating toys to Safe Space, which is Judge Mills Francis’ favorite charity. It is not clear on whether or not these donations were tax-deductible.

Meanwhile, I’ve been running up thousands of dollars in legal bills with a lawyer who kept telling me that Zuniga is a hard-ass prosecutor who refuses to budge on my case. According to my attorney, Zuniga offered a deal in which he would drop most of the charges if only I plead guilty to one of the charges (it may have been the obstructing traffic charge or perhaps the disobeying a police officer charge).

Or maybe it was a deal where I enter some type of program where I’m not really “guilty” but I’m not really “innocent”. Hell, it might have even been a deal where I donate toys to a charity, but I know it wasn’t in exchange for the dismissal of my case.

The truth is, I don’t even remember the details because I rejected them outright. I am basically asking them to drop my entire case, so anything else is not even absorbed. I didn’t come this far to cop a plea deal. For that, I might as well have accepted “time served” the morning I was released from jail.If I didn’t believe I was completely innocent of all the charges against me, then I wouldn’t be raising so much hell about it.

Besides, police have done nothing but contradict themselves in this case, starting from the moment they wrote the arrest report in which they stated that I was standing in the middle of the street when they first spotted me, to them escorting me to the middle of the street a few moments later (not even these cops were that dumb to escort me to the middle of busy Biscayne Blvd in the name of safety).

The truth is, I was standing in the construction zone on the west side of the road when they first spotted me, and then I was escorted across the street to the east sidewalk after they spotted me. And once on the other side of the street, I was ordered to continue walking north on the sidewalk, which was when I took the picture in the header of this blog.

I was not interfering with the investigation for the investigation was already complete, as one officer admitted in a deposition. This would also explain why all five cops abandoned the person they were dealing to come after me.

I was not obstructing traffic for I was standing in a non-traffic zone. And I was not refusing a police order for these orders were unlawful.

I, as a citizen, had every right to observe the police in their line of duty. I had every right to photograph the police in their line of duty. And I had every right to continue standing on the sidewalk (after they had escorted me there) without having to “keep moving” as they continually ordered. This is not Cuba.

Numerous court cases have proven that these actions are protected under the First Amendment, which is why I couldn’t understand Zuniga offering these half-ass plea deals. Perhaps he missed that day in his Constitutional Law class. He obviously missed some fundamental training for the guy lasted only five months in the Miami-Dade State Attorney’s Office (and he has yet to update his LinkedIn profile, by the way).

And speaking of lack of training, the police in this case were completely unprofessional as they barked out unlawful orders; tackling me to the sidewalk and pounding my head into the pavement, destroying a camera flash, damaging a camera lens and threatening to tase me before sending me to the county jail for 16 hours.

So there is no way I am going to accept a plea deal unless it is the dismissal of my entire case. I’ll take my chances with a jury.

And I’ll take comfort in the fact that the judge presiding over my case has a charitable heart.

Comments

Anonymous
Anonymous

Manuel,

If I accept any plea deal, I would regret it for the rest of my life.

I’m going full forward with this even if I have to max out all my credit cards.

Anonymous
Anonymous

Carlos,

Good for you man. I sure hope you have a good attorney.

Anonymous
Anonymous

Great story. I can imagine what kind of toys they were bartering with, too.

Anonymous
Anonymous

Carlos:

Do not compromise your principles. You have a chance of becoming the “Peter Zenger of Photography.” A plea is the last thing you should take and a dismissal is the last thing you should want. Vindication or nothing. As for the judge having a “charitable heart,” hope instead that she has a good judicial mind. You don’t need charity; you need justice. Good luck.

Anonymous
Anonymous

[...] trial has yet to be scheduled and I imagine with the recent firing of the prosecutor in my case, which happens to involve the judge overseeing my case, it might be a [...]

Anonymous
Anonymous

What a jackass you are. I suggest that you get your facts straight before reporting false information. I am sure that as a reporter that you are aware of the dangers of libel…

Anonymous
Anonymous

Anon,

I reported what was in the Herald.

If you are so knowledgeable about the situation, please inform me what is libelous.

Anonymous
Anonymous

I witnessed a similar story on the news. They praised this as a community service-like plea deal. Did all those people get fired too? Although it seemed like all minor violations

Anonymous
Anonymous

From what I heard, the only cases that were dismissed were for people jumping the turnstile at subway stations. What I don’t get is why did all these people get fired, when in 2006 a Judge in Felony Court did the same thing. And those were felonies! I remember seeing it on the news. Here is the link

http://video.aol.com/video-detail/judge-trades-toys-for-fines-in-miami/4...

Anonymous
Anonymous

VC,

Thanks for posting that video. It really does make one wonder why Zuniga got fired, especially considering he was only dealing with misdemeanors.

The Herald should have done a better job of looking into the matter, such ask, asking the Miami-Dade State Attorney’s Office about the story you posted.

For all we know, they may have even reported on the same story in 2006.

Maybe they fired Zuniga for some other reasons and they’re just using that as an excuse.

I wish I had been given the opportunity to donate toys in exchange for my case being dropped.

Anonymous
Anonymous

Nice site… Cool guestbook…f

Anonymous
Anonymous

Carlos,

While I applaud your standing up for your rights, I can’t see how the donating toys to have your charges dropped would have been an acceptable outcome for you?

Yes, the charges would have been dropped but “they” would have “won” by not being called to task for their unconstitutional violation and the next guy would have to fight the fight.

Anonymous
Anonymous

Bruce,

I was mostly being sarcastic on this post, knowing that I had made such a ruckus about my arrest, there was no way they were going to drop it.

Anonymous
Anonymous

My bad. I missed the sarcasm. Probably due to it being the first time I’ve come across your site. It’s bookmarked now and I look forward to reading of a positive outcome on yoru appeal.

Post new comment

Pixiq on Facebook

Join the 10203 Pixiq fans on Facebook

Share

  • Share

Subscribe

Get weekly updates from Pixiq. Short, sweet, and always interesting.